Home
New rules on animal testing must take India forward, not backwards: Maneka Gandhi Officials maintain the changes seek to simplify approvals for research institutions, pharmaceutical and biomedical industries. Updated on: Oct 26, 2026, 14:54:47 IST By Jasjeev Gandhiok Prefer HTPrefer HT Prefer HT on Google Share The Centre’s draft rules governing animal experimentation have triggered concerns among animal rights groups, which say the changes could weaken independent oversight and make it easier for laboratories to conduct experiments on animals. However, officials maintain the changes seek to simplify approvals for research institutions, pharmaceutical and biomedical industries. Former Union minister Maneka Gandhi. Former Union minister Maneka Gandhi. HT speaks to animal rights activist and former Union minister Maneka Gandhi, a long-time campaigner against animal experimentation. Edited excerpts: A major change to animal experimentation, proposed in the draft, is that mild and moderate experiments could be approved by an institution’s own ethics committee rather than going to the central regulator. In practical terms, what does this change mean for an animal inside a laboratory? Does it make it easier for more animals to be experimented on? It means the animal loses the one independent pair of eyes that was looking at its fate. Today, experiments on animals larger than a rat go to the central regulator, and there is at least someone outside the building asking whether this experiment is necessary at all. Under the draft, the people who want to do the experiment, their colleagues and their department heads will be the ones approving it. And it is the institution itself, through its own veterinarian, that decides whether the experiment is mild or moderate in the first place. No institution has ever turned down its own funding. So yes, it will make it easier, and it will make it faster, and that means more animals. Mild and moderate are also the bulk of experiments, so we are effectively handing over most of animal experimentation in India to self regulation. The draft classifies experiments as mild, moderate, severe and non-recovery. Is there a concern that the institution conducting the research will effectively decide how severe the experiment is. Does this leave a grey area? It isn’t grey, it is completely black. Under this draft, the institution that wants to do the experiment is also the one that decides which category it falls into. That decision matters enormously, because if the experiment is classified as mild or moderate, the institution’s own committee approves it and it never goes to the central regulator. Only severe and non-recovery experiments on larger animals go outside. So the same people who want the experiment approved are deciding whether anyone independent will ever examine it. That is a clear conflict of interest, and it will push experiments towards the lower categories. Starving a rat for a day is called mild. Keeping a social animal alone in a cage is mild. Starving it for two days, or putting it through distress it cannot escape, is moderate. So is testing herbal products, testing established drugs, and anything described as having “known and reversible effects,” which could mean almost anything. This is not a scientific list. It is the most common commercial work. The draft also creates exceptions and allows laboratories to use animals from open markets, unregistered sources, and in certain circumstances, stray, feral, wild and protected animals. What is the biggest risk that this may create for animals in practice? Could community dogs, lost pets or animals taken from the wild find their way into laboratories? The biggest risk is that nobody will know where an animal came from. The whole point of registered breeders was traceability. Once you allow open markets and unregistered sources for cattle, goats, birds and fish, you create a demand, and in this country demand is met very quickly by people who will pick up anything. Strays and wild animals can be used if a “competent authority” permits it, and the draft never says who that is. Community dogs, someone’s lost pet, birds from illegal markets, all of it can find its way into a laboratory. These exceptions should be removed completely. If a lab cannot get an animal from a registered source, it should not be doing that experiment. The draft formally incorporates the principles of replacement, reduction and refinement, but critics say these safeguards become weaker if institutions themselves are approving experiments. Do you believe India should now be moving towards replacing animal experiments altogether, particularly when the health ministry has already allowed certain drug testing through non-animal methods? What should the rules do differently? Yes, and we are not starting from zero. The health ministry has already amended the drug rules to accept non-animal methods. The world is moving this way because these methods are often more predictive for humans than a mouse ever was. Writing replacement, reduction and refinement into the rules means nothing if the person checking compliance is the institution itself. The rules should make it mandatory to show that no validated alternative exists before an animal is used, set up a national body to validate and promote alternatives, put money into them, and set timelines to phase out animal use in areas where alternatives are already available. A rule that only mentions replacement as a principle is decoration. You have worked on animal experimentation regulation for decades. What specific changes would you want the government to make to this draft? I don’t think this draft can be fixed. There is hardly a provision in it that doesn’t need changing, and when everything needs to change, it is better to start again. So the draft should be put aside and written afresh, this time with independent scientists, animal welfare organisations and legal experts at the table. The new rules must take India forward, not backwards. Animals already have certain protections under the law which cannot be taken away. New should be building on them.

Orissa High Court Rules SC/ST Status Cannot Be Carried Across State Borders

Supreme Court Seeks Centre’s Response to Challenge Against Chhattisgarh Anti-Conversion Law

Lula’s Brazil Re-Election: What It Means for India’s Trade, Rare Earths and Global South Push

IAF Chief AP Singh Flies Final Sortie in Kiran Aircraft, Reunites With First Flying Instructor

Rubio Backs India’s Energy Diversification, Offers US Support Amid Russian Oil Debate
Trending Tags
- Movie
- Music
Trending
India
World News
Business
More
Opinion

Login
Register

No Result

View All Result

No Result

View All Result

Oil Prices Inch Upward as Markets Await OPEC+ Decision; Black Sea Storm Disrupts Supply Chains

Global oil markets experience a slight surge amid anticipation of OPEC+ decisions, while a Black Sea storm causes disruptions to oil supply chains.

November 29, 2023

Reading Time: 2 mins read

Oil Prices Inch Upward as Markets Await OPEC+ Decision; Black Sea Storm Disrupts Supply Chains

Oil Prices Inch Upward as Markets Await OPEC+ Decision; Black Sea Storm Disrupts Supply Chains

Oil prices witnessed a marginal increase today as investors awaited the outcome of the OPEC+ meeting, while a storm in the Black Sea added an element of uncertainty by causing disruptions to supply chains.

RELATED POSTS

Pope Pleads with COP28 to Find Breakthrough on Climate Change

Ukraine Receives 300,000 Shells from EU Out of Promised Million, Confirms Foreign Minister

COP28 Summit: Climate Talks Thrust Future of Fossil Fuels into the Spotlight

Market analysts and oil investors are closely monitoring the OPEC+ meeting, where decisions regarding production levels and supply adjustments are expected to be announced. The anticipation has led to a cautious optimism in the oil market, resulting in a modest uptick in prices.

A storm in the Black Sea has hampered maritime operations, affecting oil supply routes. The adverse weather conditions have disrupted shipping and logistics, temporarily slowing down the transportation of oil from key producing regions. This unexpected disruption has added an external factor influencing the current oil market dynamics.

The dual factors of OPEC+ decisions and the Black Sea storm have contributed to a mixed sentiment in the oil market. While the anticipation of potential production adjustments has provided some support, the supply chain disruptions have injected an element of volatility, prompting cautious trading among investors.

The OPEC+ meeting is expected to address the ongoing challenges in the global oil market, including the delicate balance between supply and demand. Industry experts are keenly observing whether the alliance will choose to maintain current production levels or make adjustments to accommodate changing market conditions.

Oil prices play a pivotal role in global economic dynamics, influencing inflation rates and the overall cost of living. Any decisions made by OPEC+ and unexpected disruptions in supply chains can have ripple effects on economies worldwide, making these developments critical for both producers and consumers.

The oil market is likely to experience fluctuations in the coming days as the impact of the Black Sea storm unfolds and the outcomes of the OPEC+ meeting become clearer. Investors and industry stakeholders are advised to remain vigilant in response to these rapidly evolving market conditions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tags: BlackSeaStorm EnergyMarket GlobalEconomy OilPrices OPEC SupplyChainDisruption

News Desk

A passionate news person, trying to reflect her views on the recent happenings around the globe, bringing you a nuanced perspective and keeping the ethics of journalism alive in the process. My journey started in an international newsroom, where I have covered major events and been to the roots of them. The South-Asian region has also caught my interest, where I have covered more of the features and cultural side of the South-Asian countries. As a journalist dedicated to ethical reporting and with a personal interest in exposing hidden narratives, I aim to offer complex perspectives that enhance comprehension of the modern, globalized world.

Related Posts

Login
Sign Up

Copyright © 2022 India Reflects - India Reflects Ltd. All Rights Reserved.