• Home
    • All
    • Art
    • Bollywood
    • Business
    • Cricket
    • Crypto
    • Culture
    • Daily Horoscope
    • Economy
    • Elections
    • Entertainment
    • Fashion
    • Gaming
    • Health
    • History
    • India
    • Lifestyle
    • Movie Reviews
    • Photos
    • Politics
    • Sci-Tech
    • Science
    • Sports
    • Tech
    • Trending
    • TV
    • Uncategorized
    • Web Series
    • World News
    Trump May Hold Off on Fresh Iran Attacks if Tehran Avoids Provocation, Report Says

    Trump May Hold Off on Fresh Iran Attacks if Tehran Avoids Provocation, Report Says

    Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

    Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

    Type 2 Diabetes: Endocrinologist Reveals 6 Lesser-Known Warning Signs, From Unusual Fatigue to Slow-Healing Wounds

    Type 2 Diabetes: Endocrinologist Reveals 6 Lesser-Known Warning Signs, From Unusual Fatigue to Slow-Healing Wounds

    Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

    Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

    Trump Weighs Ousting Meghan Bauer! White House Cabinet Secretary Faces Exit Amid Post-Midterm Shake-Up

    Trump Weighs Ousting Meghan Bauer! White House Cabinet Secretary Faces Exit Amid Post-Midterm Shake-Up

    SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

    SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

    Trending Tags

    • Movie
    • Music
  • Trending
  • India
    • Politics
    • States
    • Elections
    • Results
  • World News
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Real Estate
    • Crypto
  • More
    • Entertainment
      • Bollywood
      • TV
      • Movie Reviews
      • Web Series
    • Sports
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Games
    • Sci-Tech
      • Science
      • Tech
      • Gadgets
      • Gaming
    • Culture
      • History
      • Festivals
      • Art
      • Temples
      • Scriptures
    • Lifestyle
      • Fashion
      • Food
      • Health
      • Travel
    • Student’s Corner
      • Exam
      • Exam Results
      • Schools
      • Universities
    • Astrology
      • Daily Horoscope
      • Monthly Horoscope
      • Days
  • Opinion
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
    • All
    • Art
    • Bollywood
    • Business
    • Cricket
    • Crypto
    • Culture
    • Daily Horoscope
    • Economy
    • Elections
    • Entertainment
    • Fashion
    • Gaming
    • Health
    • History
    • India
    • Lifestyle
    • Movie Reviews
    • Photos
    • Politics
    • Sci-Tech
    • Science
    • Sports
    • Tech
    • Trending
    • TV
    • Uncategorized
    • Web Series
    • World News
    Trump May Hold Off on Fresh Iran Attacks if Tehran Avoids Provocation, Report Says

    Trump May Hold Off on Fresh Iran Attacks if Tehran Avoids Provocation, Report Says

    Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

    Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

    Type 2 Diabetes: Endocrinologist Reveals 6 Lesser-Known Warning Signs, From Unusual Fatigue to Slow-Healing Wounds

    Type 2 Diabetes: Endocrinologist Reveals 6 Lesser-Known Warning Signs, From Unusual Fatigue to Slow-Healing Wounds

    Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

    Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

    Trump Weighs Ousting Meghan Bauer! White House Cabinet Secretary Faces Exit Amid Post-Midterm Shake-Up

    Trump Weighs Ousting Meghan Bauer! White House Cabinet Secretary Faces Exit Amid Post-Midterm Shake-Up

    SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

    SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

    Trending Tags

    • Movie
    • Music
  • Trending
  • India
    • Politics
    • States
    • Elections
    • Results
  • World News
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Real Estate
    • Crypto
  • More
    • Entertainment
      • Bollywood
      • TV
      • Movie Reviews
      • Web Series
    • Sports
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Games
    • Sci-Tech
      • Science
      • Tech
      • Gadgets
      • Gaming
    • Culture
      • History
      • Festivals
      • Art
      • Temples
      • Scriptures
    • Lifestyle
      • Fashion
      • Food
      • Health
      • Travel
    • Student’s Corner
      • Exam
      • Exam Results
      • Schools
      • Universities
    • Astrology
      • Daily Horoscope
      • Monthly Horoscope
      • Days
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
India Reflects
No Result
View All Result
Home India

If Pranab Mukherjee Had Been PM, Manmohan Singh as President: Mani Shankar Aiyar Reflects in New Book

Senior Congress Leader Critiques UPA-II Leadership Decisions, Links Them to Party Decline

News Desk by News Desk
December 15, 2024
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
Former president Pranab Mukherjee (left) with former prime minister Manmohan Singh.(PTI file)

Former president Pranab Mukherjee (left) with former prime minister Manmohan Singh.(PTI file)

In a candid reflection on the challenges faced by the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) during its second term, senior Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar has stirred controversy by suggesting that Pranab Mukherjee should have been made Prime Minister in 2012, with Dr. Manmohan Singh elevated to the presidency. These remarks, part of his book A Maverick in Politics, critique key leadership decisions that he claims contributed to a “paralysis of governance” and the eventual downfall of UPA-II.

RELATED POSTS

Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

Aiyar, who served as a minister during UPA-I, argues that the Congress’s decision to retain Singh as Prime Minister and appoint Mukherjee as President “doomed any prospects” of the party forming UPA-III. He further pointed out that Singh’s health issues and Congress president Sonia Gandhi’s illness in 2012 led to a leadership vacuum, compounded by mismanagement of critical events like Anna Hazare’s ‘India Against Corruption’ movement.

A Missed Opportunity for Leadership Realignment

Reflecting on the dynamics of 2012, Aiyar wrote, “The choice of Rashtrapati: Manmohan Singh or Pranab Mukherjee. Personally, I was of the view that Pranab Mukherjee should have been given the reins of the government, and Dr Manmohan Singh elevated to President of India when the office of Rashtrapati presented an opening.”

According to Aiyar, Pranab Mukherjee’s vast experience and active political persona could have revitalized the government during a critical juncture. Meanwhile, Dr. Singh, a figure of “high distinction,” would have been better suited to the ceremonial yet influential role of President. He cited Mukherjee’s memoirs, which suggested that such a move was indeed contemplated but never realized.

Fallout of Leadership Choices

The former diplomat painted a grim picture of the consequences of these decisions. “Dr. Singh’s health issues slowed him down, and this showed up in governance. As for the party, there was no official announcement about Sonia Gandhi’s health, leading to stasis and an absence of effective leadership,” he noted.

Aiyar did not shy away from linking the leadership choices to the broader political consequences. He argued that the “paralysis of governance” allowed “the worst excesses of Hindutva” to take root, paving the way for the BJP’s resounding victory in the 2014 general elections.

Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Vague Impressions’

Citing Mukherjee’s reflections, Aiyar claimed that Sonia Gandhi had given a “vague impression” of considering Dr. Singh as a presidential nominee during her holiday in the Kausambi hills. Mukherjee, in turn, speculated that this might open the door for him to become Prime Minister. However, the Congress leadership eventually chose to retain Singh as PM and appointed Mukherjee as President, a decision Aiyar deemed a historic blunder.

Buy JNews
ADVERTISEMENT

Balancing Governance and Public Perception

Aiyar’s critique extends beyond internal party dynamics to the broader implications of leadership on public perception. He recalled how international and domestic media criticized the UPA government, with Time magazine famously dubbing Dr Singh a “Do Nothing” Prime Minister. This negative coverage further weakened the UPA’s standing.

The “Left-Wing” Factor

Acknowledging potential challenges, Aiyar admitted that Mukherjee’s “Left-wing reputation” might have caused apprehensions among the business community and the United States. However, he maintained that Mukherjee’s leadership could have steered the government away from paralysis and provided a more robust response to political crises.

Aiyar’s revelations serve as a reflection on missed opportunities and the impact of leadership decisions on political trajectories. By revisiting these pivotal moments, he raises critical questions about the interplay of health, governance, and political strategy in shaping the course of Indian politics. His book adds to the ongoing discourse on the legacy of UPA-II and its ramifications for the Congress party.

 

Tags: 2012 governance crisisAnna Hazare movementCongress leadershipHindutvaIndia Against CorruptionIndian PoliticsMani Shankar AiyarManmohan SinghPranab MukherjeeSonia GandhiUPA-IIUPA-III
Share197Tweet123
News Desk

News Desk

A passionate news person, trying to reflect her views on the recent happenings around the globe, bringing you a nuanced perspective and keeping the ethics of journalism alive in the process. My journey started in an international newsroom, where I have covered major events and been to the roots of them.  The  South-Asian region has also caught my interest, where I have covered more of the features and cultural side of the South-Asian countries. As a journalist dedicated to ethical reporting and with a personal interest in exposing hidden narratives, I aim to offer complex perspectives that enhance comprehension of the modern, globalized world.

Related Posts

Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue

November 14, 2026
Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery

November 14, 2026
SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

SpiceJet Crisis Deepens: Mass Flight Cancellations, Financial Turmoil Raise Questions Over Passenger Rights

November 14, 2026
BrahMos Missile Push: Philippines Gets Supply, Vietnam Signs Agreement As Southeast Asian Nations Show Interest

BrahMos Missile Push: Philippines Gets Supply, Vietnam Signs Agreement As Southeast Asian Nations Show Interest

November 14, 2026
Diwali 2026: Psychologist Explains How to Beat Festive Stress and Let Go of Perfection

Diwali 2026: Psychologist Explains How to Beat Festive Stress and Let Go of Perfection

November 14, 2026
MSRTC Announces ₹10,000 Diwali Bonus for 83,000 Employees, Raises DA to 60%

MSRTC Announces ₹10,000 Diwali Bonus for 83,000 Employees, Raises DA to 60%

November 14, 2026
Live Cricket Scores
en English
en Englishgu Gujaratihi Hindikn Kannadaml Malayalammr Marathipa Punjabita Tamilte Telugu

Recommended Stories

Saif Ali Khan attack: Both security guards were sleeping when Bangladeshi national entered, say cops

Saif Ali Khan attack: Both security guards were sleeping when Bangladeshi national entered, say cops

January 22, 2025
Pema Khandu has been the Arunachal Pradesh chief minister since July 2016 when he first took oath as head of a Congress government (X/PemaKhanduBJP)

Pema Khandu Elected Arunachal BJP Legislature Party Leader; Oath as CM Tomorrow

June 12, 2024
Protests in Bengaluru Over River Water Sharing Lead to Police Detentions

Protests in Bengaluru Over River Water Sharing Lead to Police Detentions

September 26, 2023

Popular Stories

  • Incredible Health Benefits of Walking 5,000 Steps a Day

    Incredible Health Benefits of Walking 5,000 Steps a Day

    824 shares
    Share 330 Tweet 206
  • Jeet Adani Asks Anupam Mittal To Remove His Shaadi.com Profile Days Before Wedding To Diva Shah

    599 shares
    Share 240 Tweet 150
  • UK Welcomes PM Modi – Wembley Stadium

    557 shares
    Share 223 Tweet 139
  • Mangalyaan: India’s Mars Orbiter craft quietly bids goodbye

    533 shares
    Share 213 Tweet 133
  • “Vikram Vedha”; 15 cities receive live broadcasts of the song

    530 shares
    Share 212 Tweet 133
India Reflects

India Reflects

India's first truly global news portal brings you unbiased news based on facts from India and around the World.

Recent Posts

  • Trump May Hold Off on Fresh Iran Attacks if Tehran Avoids Provocation, Report Says
  • Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik Likely to Visit India from November 20-22 for SCO Civilizational Dialogue
  • Type 2 Diabetes: Endocrinologist Reveals 6 Lesser-Known Warning Signs, From Unusual Fatigue to Slow-Healing Wounds
  • Medicine Is the Real Test of AI: Siddhartha Mukherjee Says India Has a Historic Opportunity to Transform Drug Discovery
  • Trump Weighs Ousting Meghan Bauer! White House Cabinet Secretary Faces Exit Amid Post-Midterm Shake-Up

Categories

  • Art
  • Bollywood
  • Business
  • Cricket
  • Crypto
  • Culture
  • Daily Horoscope
  • Economy
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Gaming
  • Health
  • History
  • India
  • Lifestyle
  • Movie Reviews
  • Photos
  • Politics
  • Sci-Tech
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Trending
  • TV
  • Uncategorized
  • Web Series
  • World News

Policy Pages

Privacy Policy

Copyright Policy

Terms Of Use

Disclaimer

Code of Ethics

Copyright © 2022 India Reflects - India Reflects Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Home
  • Trending
  • India
    • Politics
    • States
    • Elections
    • Results
  • World News
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Real Estate
    • Crypto
  • Entertainment
    • Bollywood
    • TV
    • Movie Reviews
    • Web Series
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Games
  • Sci-Tech
    • Science
    • Tech
    • Gadgets
    • Gaming
  • Culture
    • History
    • Festivals
    • Art
    • Temples
    • Scriptures
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Travel
  • Student’s Corner
    • Exam
    • Exam Results
    • Schools
    • Universities
  • Astrology
    • Daily Horoscope
    • Monthly Horoscope
    • Days
  • Opinion

Copyright © 2022 India Reflects - India Reflects Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist